Samantha is of course very close to Rebecca's period. Samantha is living in 1904, and Rebecca is living in 1914.
Samantha belongs to the Edwardian period, which is from 1901-1910. Nonetheless, Samantha is often described as being Victorian, and Rebecca is often described as Edwardian. Neither of these is correct!
So deciding which pattern belongs to which doll may require some research.
However, if it is sleeveless, you can rule it out for Samantha. Grandmary wouldn't let her wear it.
A few patterns work for either doll. This includes:
Anne Van Doren Designs Edwardian Style Dress and Apron
Anne Van Doren Designs Victorian Style Underwear
Jen Wrenne FREE Sailor Dress Pattern
Keeper's Dolly Duds Simplicity 1179 Vintage Inspired Clothes
Bunny Bear's 1900 Sailor Dress Pattern
If a pattern specifically has a date on it that is 1910 or later, Samantha probably shouldn't wear it.
These patterns are specifically for Samantha:
Dolls at Hearts Designs Edwardian Day Dress
Farmcookies Welcome Back Samantha
Heritage Doll Fashions Samantha's Ice Cream Dress
Keepers Dolly Duds Reefer Jacket and Hat
Keepers Dolly Duds Victorian Christmas Caroler
Lincoln Mold 1904 Bathing Suit that fits American Girls Dolls
Lincoln Mold 1904 Undergarments that fits American Girl Dolls
Lincoln Mold 1904 Girls Coat and Hat that fits American Girls Dolls
Lincoln Mold 1904 Dress that fits American Girl Dolls Patterns 40, 41 and 42
Pleasant Company Samantha Patterns at AG Playthings
Wren*Feathers Edwardian Heirloom Pattern Set
Grandmary was so strict that Samantha could be wearing all or part of the Thimbles and Acorns Victorian Unmentionables as well.
Elsewhere on the web:
Fancy Frocks 1904 Sailor Dress
Fancy Frocks 1905 Sam's Winter Frock
Okay, that's a short list.
Inspiration for further Samantha dresses can be found at The Bleu Door. This shows dress patterns produces for Bluette dolls, and you can search by year and decade. The earliest year is 1905, which is admittedly a year late, but still very close to Samantha's period. If you assume she got the dress after Christmas, it works just fine.
I just had this pink fabric lying around, so here is another Faux Button Jumper from the Forever 18 Inches pattern . Yeah, I was ru...
Well, this year's sale was different. My extremely beloved guinea pig stopped eating the day before the sale. On the day of the sale...
This is another post using the photos from Nicolel at American Girl Playthings. She is so kind! She made these great side-by-side c...
Molly is one of my least favorite AG. I just never bonded with her personality. I owned the doll briefly, but sold her so that someone else ...